Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
+{{htmlmetatags>metatag-keywords=(first appeal vs second appeal rti,first appeal rti,second appeal cic,second appeal sic,section 19 1 vs section 19 3 rti,rti appeal difference)&metatag-description=(First Appeal vs Second Appeal under the RTI Act — who hears it, how long, what each can do, costs, evidence rules, and when each is the right choice. With a ready-to-use flowchart for applicants.)}}
+====== First Appeal vs Second Appeal — the RTI appeal chain explained ======
+**A First Appeal under Section 19(1) is heard by the First Appellate Authority (FAA) — an officer one rank above the PIO, within the same public authority — within 30 days of the PIO's decision. A Second Appeal under Section 19(3) is heard by the Central or State Information Commission within 90 days of the FAA's decision. The First Appeal is mandatory and intermediate; the Second Appeal is the final administrative remedy. Writ petition to the High Court under Article 226 follows only when the Commission's order is legally flawed.**
+{{page>_snippets:dpdp-banner}}
+===== Side-by-side comparison =====
+^ **Aspect** ^ **First Appeal (§19(1))** ^ **Second Appeal (§19(3))** ^
+| Who hears it | **First Appellate Authority (FAA)** — senior to the PIO in the same public authority | **CIC** (Central matters) or **SIC** (State matters) — an independent statutory body |
+| Filing deadline | **30 days** from PIO decision / expiry of §7(1) | **90 days** from FAA decision / expiry of §19(6) |
+| Delay condonable? | Yes — §19(1) proviso, on "sufficient cause" | Yes — §19(3) discretionary |
+| Forum location | PIO's own public authority | Separate — CIC at Delhi, SICs at state capital |
+| Fee | Nil under Central Rules; Rs 20-50 in a few States | Nil under Central Rules; some States charge Rs 20-50 |
+| Disposal timeline | **30 days**, extendable to **45** with written reasons (§19(6)) | No strict statutory limit; in practice 6-18 months depending on backlog |
+| Burden of proof | On the public authority (§19(5)) | On the public authority (§19(5)) |
+| Powers | Affirm, reverse, modify PIO decision; direct disclosure; direct fresh severance | All of the above + §19(8)(a) structural remedies + §19(8)(b) compensation + §20 penalty recommendation |
+| Order form required | Speaking (reasoned) order | Speaking order — appellate/final |
+| Further remedy | Second Appeal (§19(3)) | High Court writ under Article 226 |
+===== The appeal chain — flow =====
+<code>
+              ┌─────────────────────────────┐
+              │  Your RTI application (§6)  │
+              └──────────────┬──────────────┘
+                             ▼
+              ┌─────────────────────────────┐
+              │  PIO decision within 30 days │
+              │      — or deemed refusal     │
+              └──────────────┬──────────────┘
+                             ▼
+              ┌─────────────────────────────┐
+              │  Unsatisfied?                │
+              │  Within 30 days:             │
+              │  FIRST APPEAL (§19(1))       │
+              │  to FAA (senior to PIO)      │
+              └──────────────┬──────────────┘
+                             ▼
+              ┌─────────────────────────────┐
+              │  FAA decision within 30-45d  │
+              │      — or deemed refusal     │
+              └──────────────┬──────────────┘
+                             ▼
+              ┌─────────────────────────────┐
+              │  Still unsatisfied?          │
+              │  Within 90 days:             │
+              │  SECOND APPEAL (§19(3))      │
+              │  to CIC / SIC               │
+              └──────────────┬──────────────┘
+                             ▼
+              ┌─────────────────────────────┐
+              │  Commission order             │
+              │  — binding; implementation    │
+              │    reports may be called for  │
+              └──────────────┬──────────────┘
+                             ▼
+              ┌─────────────────────────────┐
+              │  Legal flaw in order?         │
+              │  Writ petition to HC          │
+              │  under Article 226            │
+              └─────────────────────────────┘
+</code>
+===== What First Appeal can — and cannot — do =====
+**First Appeal CAN:**
+  * Direct the PIO to provide specific information
+  * Direct fresh §10 severance (release of non-exempt portion with reasons)
+  * Direct a fresh §11 third-party consultation if it was skipped
+  * Vary or waive fee calculations (§7(3))
+  * Refer to the Commission for §20 penalty examination
+**First Appeal CANNOT:**
+  * Directly impose §20 penalty (that's a Commission power)
+  * Award compensation under §19(8)(b) (also Commission-only)
+  * Bind subsequent FAAs (its orders are decision-specific, not precedential)
+===== What Second Appeal can do — beyond First Appeal's powers =====
+  * **Structural remedies (§19(8)(a))** — direct the public authority to (i) appoint a PIO, (ii) revise §4 disclosure, (iii) change record-keeping practice, (iv) publish data proactively.
+  * **Compensation (§19(8)(b))** — award money to the applicant for loss or detriment.
+  * **§20 penalty** — impose Rs 250/day up to Rs 25,000 on the PIO, recover personally.
+  * **§20(2) disciplinary-action recommendation** — refer for departmental action under service rules.
+===== Practical differences that matter =====
+**Speed** — First Appeal resolves in **45 days max** (by statute). Second Appeal often takes **6-18 months** in practice due to Commission backlog. For time-sensitive information (journalism, court deadlines), First Appeal is far faster.
+**Independence** — The FAA is within the same public authority as the PIO. Organisational loyalty sometimes colours the order. The Commission is an independent statutory body — more robust scrutiny of facts and law.
+**Evidence depth** — First Appeal is typically documentary; the FAA may call the file. The Commission can take oral evidence, summon officers, and review the full record.
+**Legal costs** — Both are free or nominal. Writ to High Court (next step) involves court fees and usually counsel.
+===== When to skip First Appeal (if ever) =====
+**Rarely.** §19(3) requires a First Appeal to have been filed before Second Appeal. The only exceptions:
+  * **FAA non-decision**: if the FAA fails to decide within §19(6), you can file Second Appeal on the "deemed refusal" by the FAA itself.
+  * **FAA not appointed**: if the public authority has failed to designate an FAA at all, the Second Appeal lies directly — but confirm this via the §4(1)(b)(xvi) disclosure before assuming.
+Do NOT skip First Appeal on the theory that "the FAA is biased" — the Act does not recognise that ground, and Second Appeal will bounce for non-exhaustion.
+===== Templates (pointers) =====
+  * **[[:templates:first-appeal|First Appeal template — Section 19(1)]]**
+  * **[[:templates:second-appeal|Second Appeal template — Section 19(3)]]**
+  * **[[:tools:first-appeal-builder-app|First Appeal Builder — fill-in tool]]**
+===== Related =====
+  * **[[:faa-first-appeal-timelines|First Appeal timelines]]**
+  * **[[:faa-speaking-order-guide|FAA Speaking-Order Guide]]**
+  * **[[:faa-appellate-review-checklist|FAA appellate-review checklist]]**
+  * **[[:faa-section-19-8-powers|§19(8) powers in detail]]**
+  * **[[:pio-rti-reply-guide|PIO RTI Reply Guide]]**
+----
+//Posted: 22 April 2026 · Author: Shrawan Pathak, Editor RTI Wiki//
+~~NOCACHE~~
+{{tag>blog appeals §19 first-appeal second-appeal cic sic}}

Was this helpful? — views